More stories from
the campaign trail
Stories from Oct. 15-21, 2006
Editorial
Back to issues - please
Oct. 21, 2006
Voters have just two more weeks to focus on the free-for-all that is the gubernatorial contest.
This is an important election. It is the first time in 16 years that the race for governor includes four fresh faces. Given the power of incumbency, it is possible the person elected Nov. 7 could spend eight years leading the state.
This campaign began as a real debate about issues. The four candidates bring very different backgrounds to the election, none having been elected to office in their own right in the past. Republican Kerry Healey is the lieutenant governor because Mitt Romney selected her as his running mate.
In the last two weeks, however, the dialogue has careened in a different direction - spurred by Healey ads focused on Democrat Deval Patrick’s character and his defense of criminals, either as a defense attorney or in writing letters seeking clemency for a convict. While just about everything in a person’s past is fair game in the hardball world of politics, the ferocity of this attack has made the campaign ads themselves a focus.
Voters have spoken loudly, now and in previous elections, about how they dislike negative campaigning. Yet candidates persist because it works, especially when you’re behind in the polls.
Crime is an important subject for serious discussion - in contrast to ads that are just scary. The streets of Boston are awash in guns and violence. The public should be concerned about what the next governor would do to help end this plague.
Taxes and education are the other two big issues, and candidates have very different ideas for how to provide services without taxing people more. Independent Christy Mihos has a novel plan: to dedicate 40 percent of state tax revenue to local aid. Grace Ross, the Green-Rainbow Party candidate, has brought to the discussion a segment of the populace that otherwise gets no attention: the poor and those on the margins trying to cope with the affordability dilemma that colors every aspect of life in Massachusetts.
It is arrogant to suggest that Ross and Mihos have no role in the gubernatorial debates. They have won a place on the ballot and have plans that are worth hearing.
In the next 17 days TV will be awash in campaign ads. But there are other ways to find information about Healey, Patrick, Mihos and Ross. Besides reading the Ledger, you can find all the information you need on the upcoming election at patriotledger.com. Click on Your Vote 2006 for stories, profiles, and background on the candidates and the ballot questions. Or look at the candidates’ Web sites.
It’s a cop-out to say that the winner doesn’t matter. Your money, your schools, roads, public safety and quality of life are affected by people elected to office.
^ top
NEW TWIST
Patrick campaign
accuses foe
of dirty tricks
Jumpsuited ‘prisoners’
demonstrate at homes of candidate, aide
By ELAINE ALLEGRINI
SouthofBoston.com / Oct. 21, 2006
ABINGTON - The increasingly heated governor’s race apparently took another turn Friday when people dressed in orange jail-type jumpsuits showed up outside the home of John Walsh, campaign manager for Democratic candidate Deval Patrick.
Patrick spokesman Doug Rubin said the demonstrators were sent there by the campaign of the Republican candidate, Lt. Gov. Kerry Healey.
Rubin said the demonstrators frightened Walsh’s son and other youths as they left for school.
“It’s pathetic, going to John Walsh’s house and putting his family through that,” Rubin said.
Similarly garbed demonstrators were outside Thursday night’s gubernatorial debate at Faneuil Hall in Boston and also were outside Patrick’s Milton home Friday morning, according to Rubin.
“These people are consistent; they have no concern about personal attacks whatsoever,” said Allyne Pecevich of Brockton, a district coordinator for Patrick’s campaign. “I can’t imagine why they would want to scare anybody.”
Reached Friday, a spokeswoman for Healey’s campaign said she was unaware of the demonstration in Abington.
Walsh, an Abington businessman and former selectman, referred all questions to Patrick’s campaign spokesman.
The demonstrations underlined a key issue dividing the two candidates: crime. Healey has repeatedly tried to portray Patrick as soft on crime, while Patrick has said his legal actions in the past on behalf of “unsavory” defendants were in line with the U.S. Constitution.
Rubin, Patrick’s spokesman, said Walsh’s 12-year-old son, Coleman, was home alone when the orange-suited demonstrators showed up Friday morning.
“He was shaken up and worried about going out of the house,” Rubin said.
Police were called to the scene on Crossley Street at about 7 a.m., but Chief David Majenski said the demonstrators were gone when officiers arrived.
Two of Walsh’s neighbors, reached later Friday, said they did not see the demonstrators.
“I don’t believe that Kerry Healey would do that; that’s kind of low,” said Joan Talabach, an unenrolled voter who lives in Walsh’s North Abington neighborhood.
“I don’t think they should be going to places like that,” said M. Claire Burns, another neighbor. “I don’t like (Healey) anyway, I’m voting for Deval Patrick, he’s running a very good campaign.”
Voters will choose a new governor on Nov. 7.
Elaine Allegrini can be reached at eallegrini@enterprisenews.com.
^ top
Healey's gun plan slammed
Officials criticize the gubernatorial hopeful's plan to strip local police chiefs of the right to issue gun licenses.
By Terence J. Downing
ENTERPRISE STAFF WRITER / Oct. 19, 2006
TAUNTON — Taunton Police Chief Raymond L. O'Berg and Raynham Police Chief Louis J. Pacheco blasted Republican gubernatorial candidate Kerry Healey's plan to strip police chiefs of the power to issue gun permits.
The chiefs were joined by Bristol County District Attorney-elect Samuel Sutter, Mayor Robert G. Nunes, state Sen. Marc R. Pacheco and advocates against domestic violence in supporting Democratic candidate Deval Patrick's anti-crime package.
“The Romney-Healey administration has also vetoed millions of dollars for corrections, law enforcement agencies, victim programs and domestic violence and sexual-abuse services,” Nunes said outside the police station.
“Patrick will adequately fund these services so agencies like New Hope and Womansplace Crisis Center in Brockton can work with and counsel victims of these horrible crimes,” Nunes said.
He said Patrick's plan will directly benefit New Hope, which serves more than 10,000 women, children and men annually, and Womansplace, which also serves Taunton.
Nunes said local aid cuts from the Romney-Healey administration have led to the layoff of 700 police officers statewide, including Taunton, where crime has risen.
“Pre-9/11, five years ago, the city of Taunton had 118 uniformed police officers. Today we have 112,” Nunes said.
“I said crime was going to increase when we laid off police, and it has. Taunton has become a more violent city, unfortunately,” O'Berg said.
“We took it the hardest in laying off people,” O'Berg said.
Healey has proposed stripping local police chiefs of the right to issue gun licenses and instead transfer the authority to a statewide panel.
Anyone who wants a license to carry or own a gun now has to approach their local chief. Healey said that puts too much power in the hands of local officials at the expense of individuals seeking legal access to guns.
O'Berg said Healey's gun permit plan would be harmful and could allow people to slip through the cracks.
“I'm absolutely opposed to it,” O'Berg said. “The local police chief knows the community better than someone sitting in Boston. You have to have local accountability with the chiefs.”
“It's crazy. It's ridiculous,” Pacheco said. “Why fix it if it's not broken? The people that know you best in the community are the ones issuing the gun permits.”
Pacheco said someone without a criminal record may not appear to pose a danger when applying for a permit, but the local chief would know if officers have been to the person's house for disturbances or if the person has had other issues with police that make the applicant unsuitable.
Sutter said Patrick's plans will put more police officers on the streets and more prosecutors in the courtroom.
Sutter cited a situation last May when there were more judges in Taunton District Court than prosecutors.
“For two days there were four judges and only three prosecutors. You had a judge with nothing to do,” Sutter said.
“You should never have a situation where you have more judges than prosecutors,” Sutter said.
He said Patrick, because he was a prosecutor and defense attorney, “understands the needs of the police and district attorneys office better than Healey.”
Sutter said his upset win over Paul Walsh Jr. was a signal that “voters wanted change. They are concerned about increasing gun, drug and gang violence and unsolved murders. I pledged to make changes, but I need the funding to do it.”
Tim O'Brien, Healey's campaign manager, said Patrick's record shows he's soft on crime.
“Deval Patrick is afraid to talk about his own record of advocating for cop killers and rapists,” O'Brien said.
“Even more telling, however, is the list of like-minded surrogates he is sending out to attack the lieutenant governor today,” O'Brien said.
“Many of these same politicians have also supported rapist Ben LaGuer, fought to gut Melanie's Law, opposed creation of the Sex Offender Registry Board and support legislation to make drug dealers eligible for parole after serving only two-thirds of their sentence,” O'Brien said.
^ top
Healey TV ad draws angry response
Patrick supporters say TV attack plays on fears of women
By STEVE LeBLANC
Associated Press / Oct. 19, 2006
BOSTON - Kerry Healey, struggling to close a gender gap with Democratic rival Deval Patrick, is unveiling a scathing new television ad linking Patrick’s past efforts to seek parole for a convicted rapist with women’s fears of being attacked.
The ad is drawing fire from women who support Patrick and victim advocates who said the Republican candidate for governor is pandering to women in an attempt to draw votes and is ignoring the fact that the vast number of sexual assaults are committed by relatives or acquaintances, not strangers.
The ad, set to begin airing today, features grainy images of a woman walking alone in a deserted parking garage, shown from the perspective of a potential stalker or assailant, while a female narrator asks “Have you ever heard a woman compliment a rapist?”
The ad includes a clip of a television interview during which Patrick described Benjamin LaGuer as “eloquent” and “thoughtful.” LaGuer was convicted of holding hostage and raping a 59-year-old neighbor in 1983. Patrick supported LaGuer’s efforts to seek a DNA test, which later confirmed his guilt, after which Patrick dropped his support.
The ad concludes with the narrator saying: “Deval Patrick, he should be ashamed - not governor.”
Most polls show Healey trailing Patrick among female voters. Healey has referred to the LaGuer case repeatedly in the past, both at press conferences and other television ads, to portray Patrick as soft on crime. But the latest ad is a more direct appeal.
Healey defended the ad, saying it talks to the real concerns of victims and to Patrick’s “orientation and a pattern” of supporting offenders instead of victims.
“This has to do with what are Deval Patrick’s priorities,” she said. “I think when you talk about crime one of the things you have to ask is what is your basic predisposition. He and his running mate have frequently been on the side of the offender.”
The ad drew a fierce response from supporters of Patrick, who held a press conference outside the State House to denounce it.
State Sen. Marian Walsh, D-Boston, called the ad an “Alice in Wonderland attempt to frighten women.”
The ad was also drawing criticism from advocates for sexual assault victims.
^ top
Healey backs LNG site off Hull
By TOM BENNER
Patriot Ledger State House Bureau / Oct. 18, 2006
QUINCY - Republican candidate for governor Kerry Healey supports a private company’s plan to site a liquefied natural gas terminal on state-owned Outer Brewster Island - two miles off the tip of Hull.
“Of all of the various proposals to expand access to LNG, that one seems to be one that is least damaging to the fishing industry, the least problematic from a public safety standpoint,” Healey told The Patriot Ledger editorial board yesterday.
 |
LISA BÜL/The Patriot Ledger |
| Lt. Gov. Kerry Healey speaks with the Patriot Ledger editorial board. |
“The Brewster Island proposal has the virtue of not being around a population center and not being in a fishing ground,” Healey said. “Does that mean it’s my favorite? It means that it’s the least objectionable of the four proposals which I have seen so far.”
Healey’s support for an LNG terminal in Boston Harbor, as proposed by Arlington, Va.-based AES Corp., puts her at odds with her three opponents in the governor’s race. Democrat Deval Patrick said putting an LNG terminal on Outer Brewster, which is part of the the Boston Harbor Islands National Park and Recreation Area, would set a “terrible precedent.” Independent Christy Mihos supports offshore LNG terminals farther removed from population centers. Green-Rainbow candidate Grace Ross wants to import LNG instead from Canada or elsewhere instead of building terminals in Massachusetts.
With the race increasingly heated as election day approaches, Healey defended her criticism of Patrick for his work as a defense lawyer, which involved representing a cop killer in Florida.
Despite Patrick’s additional work prosecuting crime - he led the investigation into church burnings in the South in the 1990s as the U.S. Justice Department’s civil rights enforcer - Healey said Patrick hasn’t worked enough on behalf of victim’s rights.
“Both Deval Patrick and his running mate have consistently worked on the side of the accused and the offender, as opposed to working on behalf of the victim and victim’s families,” Healey said. “It shows a perspective, it’s just one aspect of his priorities.”
Healey defended her decision not to release a questionnaire she filled out for Gun Owner’s Action League, a group working to liberalize state gun restrictions that endorsed Healey’s candidacy. Healey said some police chiefs are too restrictive about granting licenses to individuals to carry firearms. She added she would consider easing restrictions on granting firearms licenses to people with criminal records.
“Really, this is a constitutional right,” Healey said. “To have one police chief applying it entirely differently than another police chief does not seem like a good situation.”
Responding to criticism that the race for governor is too negative, Healey blamed the three Democrats running in the September primary for setting the tone.
“This is a strategy that began during the Democratic primary when their whole focus was to attack me and to use very negative and distorted views of our administration’s record,” Healey said.
Healey said she expects to oppose a question on the Nov. 7 ballot that would allow wine to be sold in grocery stores, saying it will hurt small businesses and make alcohol more available to minors.
“I’m leaning toward thinking that it’s a bad idea,” Healey said.
Healey said Romney’s rightward shift on issues such as abortion and stem-cell research, and his waning interest in remaining in the governor’s job, has made it easier to set herself apart from the outgoing governor. Healey supports abortion rights and stem-cell research.
“One of the biggest challenges for lieutenant governor is to move out of the shadow of the governor, whoever the governor is, and distinguish themselves,” Healey said.
Tom Benner may be reached at tbenner@ledger.com.
^ top
More support Patrick
Governor’s race zeroes in on women
MetroWest Daily News / Oct. 18, 2006
There is a new battleground in the race for governor: the women’s vote.
Recent polls show Democratic candidate Deval Patrick with more female supporters than the Republican candidate, Lt. Gov. Kerry Healey.
Healey, who hopes to be the first woman elected governor in Massachusetts, said last week that she would bring more women and men to her side on issues such as making the state more affordable.
 |
Associated Press |
| The Planned Parenthood Advocacy Fund, the Massachusetts chapter of the National Organization for Women and NARAL Pro-Choice Massachusetts all endorsed Deval Patrick. |
Patrick, a former federal civil rights enforcer who is leading in the polls, credited his “issue-specific and constructive and positive campaign” for his support among female voters.
Former Natick Selectman Erica Ball, a Democrat, said Patrick is doing better among women because his campaign has been “issue-driven,” while Healey is running commercials attacking Patrick.
“I think her negativity strikes women the wrong way,” Ball said. ...
But Jeanne Kangas of Concord, vice chairwoman of the state Republican Party, said she believes party preferences are the main reason for Patrick’s lead among women voters.
“The women generally tend to vote more heavily Democratic than Republican ... and I think that tendency is certainly in effect in this particular case,” Kangas said.
Kangas also said she believes “there are a small but significant percentage of women who find it difficult to support a woman candidate.”
“Our culture teaches women to compete with each other for the attention and affections of men,” Kangas said. “And some women find because of these cultural pressures to not be fully supportive of other women.”
In addition, Kangas said, “Some women are envious of anyone, especially another woman, who is too thin or too rich, and that may be part of the explanation.”
“It’s difficult for women to run for public office,” said Ann Murphy, vice president of the Massachusetts Women’s Political Caucus, which has endorsed Healey.
Female candidates often struggle to build a fund-raising base, Murphy said, and worry about appearing confident but not too harsh.
“They want to be seen as aggressive and have the capacity to lead, to be a leader, (but) they also want to not appear too aggressive and not to turn anyone off,” Murphy said. “And it’s a very fine line sometimes.”
The Planned Parenthood Advocacy Fund, the Massachusetts chapter of the National Organization for Women and NARAL (National Abortion Rights Action League) Pro-Choice Massachusetts all endorsed Patrick last week.
Healey made light of the endorsements Patrick received from the three women’s groups, saying at a press conference in Framingham last Thursday that the groups are partisan. Healey also sought to distinguish herself from Romney.
Asked about her lagging poll numbers among women, Healey noted that she has been endorsed by the National Republican Pro-Choice Women and the Massachusetts Women’s Political Caucus.
“People are just starting to get engaged in this race. ... When we really start hearing more about the issues, I’ll bring people over to my side,” Healey said.
Murphy of the Massachusetts Women’s Political Caucus said the group liked Healey’s pro-choice stance and what she had to say about child care, domestic violence and helping promote equality in the workplace.
The group endorses only female candidates, Murphy said, adding that an endorsement is not a given for a female candidate not facing another woman.
Asked about his support among women last week, Patrick said: “I think it has been that issue-specific and constructive and positive campaign that explains the reason we have built as broadly and successfully as we have among women and men.”
Patrick had been leading Healey by a larger margin in earlier polls. Pundits attribute his narrowing lead to Healey’s running ads critical of Patrick’s past criminal justice work.
^ top
Presidential assist:
Clinton helps raise $2M for Patrick
By L.E. CAMPENELLA
The Patriot Ledger / Oct. 17, 2006
BOSTON —
Deval Patrick isn’t Bill Clinton, but he is close, say his supporters and converts to his candidacy.
“I’m voting for him,” said Al Saunders, 42, who was working as a bartender at the Westin Hotel in Copley Square, where former president Clinton was the major draw at a fundraiser to raise money for Patrick’s campaign for governor.
 |
Associated Press |
| Former President Bill Clinton, left, applauds as Massachusetts Democratic gubernatorial candidate Deval Patrick approaches the microphone during a Democratic fundraising event at a hotel in Boston. |
Saunders, who lives in East Boston, said he had heard Lt. Gov. Kerry Healey’s pitch for support and was ready to vote for her in the general election next month.
He said he changed his mind after listening to Patrick.
“After hearing what (Patrick) had to say, he’s different,’’ Saunders said.
Saunders’ reaction is just what the Patrick campaign was hoping for.
More than 1,200 people paid $1,000 or more Oct. 16 to hear Clinton on stage with Patrick, who had been head of the civil rights division of the Justice Department during the Clinton administration. In all, campaign officials said they expected to raise more than $2 million.
With a little more than two weeks left in the campaign, Patrick supporters said Clinton’s speech was right on time. During the last few weeks, Patrick has come under fire from the Kerry-Healey campaign for his activities in support of a cop killer in Florida and a rapist in Massachusetts.
Patrick made no excuses and no apologies, and said he would stick by his pledge not to run negative advertisements against Kerry Healey.
“As long as she keeps lying, I’ll keep telling the truth about her record,” Patrick said to a hail of applause.
The combination of a Patrick fundraiser and Bill Clinton brought out the state’s Democratic Party heavyweights, including Sen. Edward M. “Ted” Kennedy and former presidential candidate John Kerry, who praised Patrick for his service and integrity.
U.S Rep. William Delahunt, D-Quincy, said he stayed out of the primary, but once Patrick won the nomination on Sept. 19, he had to support him for reason that go beyond just the fact that Patrick is a Democrat.
“He’s something special,” Delahunt said. “When he speaks there is something visceral, something human. Something I haven’t seen since Jack Kennedy.”
L.E. Campenella may be reached at lcampenella@ledger.com.
^ top
 |
JEFF LOUGHLIN/The Patriot Ledger |
Republican candidate for governor Kerry Healey meets with supporters at the Egg and & I Too on Hancock Street in Quincy. |
Healey: I’ll lower taxes, fight crime
She campaigns
in Quincy, says
she’ll boost housing
By RACHEL SLAJDA
The Patriot Ledger / Oct. 16, 2006
QUINCY - Kerry Healey outlined the differences between Deval Patrick and her at a campaign stop in Quincy, telling supporters she would push for lower taxes and mandatory sentencing for some criminals.
Healey began the discussion at Egg & I Too by criticizing Patrick’s opposition to decreasing the income tax and what she says are his plans to increase state spending by $8 billion.
“His spending policies are out of touch with working families,” she said. “It’s very hard for me to understand how he’ll meet (his pledges) without a tax raise.”
She then asked about a dozen South Shore residents - many of them small-business owners - what they worry about most.
Amid concerns about the cost of workers’ compensation, unemployment and health insurance for employees, Healey said she would focus on making Massachusetts a more affordable place to live.
“The expense of living here is driving people out,” she said. “It’s a tragedy.”
Jami Campbell of Weymouth talked about how difficult it was to buy a bigger house for her growing family.
“The most important thing is to build more housing,” Healey said, adding she would work to make the permit process easier. Doing so, she said, will attract residential and commercial developers.
“That’s what the people in business and construction want to hear,” she said. “When can they get the shovel in the ground.”
On higher education, Healey said the state should offer incentives to students who study for “jobs of the future,” such as engineering, forensic science and nursing. If students get a degree in those fields and stay to work in Massachusetts, she said, their student loans should be forgiven.
She criticized Patrick’s proposal to grant in-state tuition to undocumented immigrants and allow them to obtain licenses to drive.
A license is the “key I.D. in our society ... to prove you are who you say you are,” she said, and it is “extremely wrong” for illegal immigrants to have them.
Healey said she wants to require identification to vote. Otherwise, she said, no checks exist on who goes to the polls.
“We could have our policies and laws impacted by people who are not even citizens of this country,” she said.
Outside the diner, she talked to reporters about Patrick’s defense of Benjamin LaGuer, who was convicted of rape.
Patrick “wants to return to Dukakis-era sentencing,” Healey said, adding Patrick is “lenient” on convicted felons.
“I’ll fight for mandatory sentences for our most dangerous sex offenders,” she said, touting her work on Ally’s Law, which broadened the definition of sexually dangerous crimes.
Rachel Slajda may be reached at rslajda@ledger.com.
^ top

|