Fear of Failure
Tattered Dreams
So Close
MCAS story updates

All Hull High school seniors pass the test.
Read story 3-6-03

Schools fear students will drop out after MCAS.
Story 3-4-03

Students Jennifer Mueller, Muna Bittar, Jonathan Galina and Joe Cao pass the MCAS after retesting.
Galina 2-28-03

Others 2-27-03

ABOUT
THE SERIES

A decade of education reform culminates this year when a students' eligibility for a high school diploma hinges on a single test for the first time in state history.

Yet four months before graduation, one in six high school seniors has yet to pass the MCAS exam.

The Patriot Ledger examines this issue, beginning with this three-part series by staff writer .

MCAS honor roll chart

South Shore results chart

Pop-up chart on MCAS Failure Rate

Pop-up chart to see who is failing

Making the Grade graphic by MICHAEL BERTRAND
/The Patriot Ledger

For the seniors - one of every six - who had not passed the exam, the December retest was their fourth shot at passing - and their last chance to receive high school diplomas in June.

 


MCAS preparation
and persistence pay off

"It's a miracle," Jonathan Galina said. "I've never been so happy in my life. I feel like I just won a million dollars."

GREG DERR/The Patriot Ledger

Jonathan Galina

Randolph High senior
exultant about passing

By DINA GERDEMAN
The Patriot Ledger

was, hands down, the best day of Jonathan Galina’s life.

After months of waiting and worrying, the Randolph High School senior yesterday found out that he passed the MCAS exam, meaning he is eligible to receive a high school diploma in June.

“It’s a miracle,” he said. “I’ve never been so happy in my life. I feel like I just won a million dollars.”

Galina was among the 10,500 high school seniors statewide who received the results of an MCAS retest exam this week. For the seniors - one of every six - who had not passed the exam, the December retest was their fourth shot at passing - and their last chance to receive high school diplomas in June. Another retest will be offered in May, but the results will not be ready in time for graduation ceremonies.

Galina, a special-needs student who had failed both the English and math sections of the MCAS test, was frustrated yesterday morning when he heard that other high schools gave students their scores but he could not receive his.

After a sleepless night of worrying about the test, Galina went to the principal’s office first thing yesterday morning, looking for his results. He was told that the scores would not be released to students until today because officials first wanted to make a presentation to the Randolph School Committee last night.
 

“He stopped the car in the middle of the street, ran in and cried in my arms like a baby.”

Barbara Galina,
Jonathan's mother

Galina, angered by the delay, drove to the school committee meeting, waited almost two hours while the committee discussed other business, then raised his hand and asked when students would get their scores. Before Galina could say he was disappointed that he did not receive his results earlier, School Superintendent Arthur Melia told him that he had passed, and that he earned some of the highest retest scores at the school: 230 in math and 238 in English, well above the passing score of 220.

Galina didn’t believe the news at first. He jumped to his feet and put his arms on top of his head.

“You know I’m Jonathan Galina?” he asked Melia.

The superintendent assured him it wasn’t a mistake.

“You should be very proud of yourself,” Melia told him. “It goes to show it can be done.”

Galina received handshakes from school committee members, and as he left the room, he fell into the arms of the school librarian and began sobbing.

Return to top

His parents were watching the school committee meeting on television and began cheering when they heard that he had passed.

“When he pulled up to the house, he didn’t even park in the driveway. He stopped the car in the middle of the street, ran in and cried in my arms like a baby,” his mother, Barbara Galina, said. “I have not seen him this happy in so long.”

Galina had attended classes during the summer and on Saturdays to prepare for the test.

Worried that he had not passed the December retest - and knowing it was his last chance before graduation - Galina started getting discouraged in the past few weeks, missing several days of school.

His mother kept telling him that even if he failed, he needed to finish high school. Although Galina always agreed with her outwardly, deep down he knew that if he failed again, he was not going back.

“I was giving up. I was thinking, ‘What’s the point?’” he said.
  With the MCAS behind him, Galina is looking forward to walking the stage on graduation day to get his diploma. And he thinks the diploma will make his college and career dreams possible.

Galina is one of five high school seniors The Patriot Ledger featured this week in a series of stories about students struggling with the MCAS exam. Four of the five students found out this week they passed. Ashley Shea, a senior at Southeastern Regional Vocational High School, missed passing by two points.

The Class of 2003 is the first required to pass both the English and math sections of the MCAS exam to graduate. Individual scores were released to schools this week. The state will release school and district results next week.

At the Randolph School Committee meeting, Galina thanked his parents, his dogs and the high school support team that helped him prepare for the test.

With the MCAS behind him, Galina is looking forward to walking the stage on graduation day to get his diploma. And he thinks the diploma will make his college and career dreams possible. He is thinking about working as a veterinary technician or as a counselor in the criminal justice system. He might even go into politics.

“There are so many careers I know I would be good at,” he said. “I’m going to be the perfect student.

“Even though I passed, my heart is broken for Ashley and everyone else who did not. I still want to send a message that it’s not right to put this anxiety on kids over one test.”

Dina Gerdeman can be reached at dgerdeman@ledger.com. Patriot Ledger reporter Fred Hanson contributed to this story. He can be reached at fhanson@ledger.com.

Return to top

 


© Copyright 2003- The Patriot Ledger ~ All rights reserved